Unauthorised development in the quarry site at Calhame, Letterkenny, Co. Donegal,

Unauthorised development in the quarry site at Calhame, Letterkenny, Co. Donegal,

LAWPRO
April 2019
WFD App lists hydromorphology as the significant pressure
Water quality impact on Broadford is confined to a 1km stretch upstream of Scotts Bridge
https://goo.gl/maps/NEbb6Pg4g9eVaLR5A
Land use and soil type indicate that the significant issue is sediment. The significant pressure is hydromorphology – channelisation: evidence of deepening and straightening.
Potential issue with quarry
The Lisheen Mine is closed, having ceased production in 2015
EPA: https://epawebapp.epa.ie/licences/lic_eDMS/rss/P0088-04.xml
The mine produced lead and zinc concentrates derived from sulphide rich ore hosted in dolomitised limestone.
Acid generating tailings from processing of the ore were deposited using the sub-aqueous technique in a fully composite lined tailings management facility (TMF), which is located on a peat bog.
The TMF is the largest fully lined tailings storage facility in Europe
Surface water run-off that falls on the TMF is converged into an engineered attenuation pond through three spillways. On exiting the pond, the surface water flows along an open channel, through another attenuation pond and out through the Clogheen stream and finally entering the Drish River.
Tailings storage at Lisheen Mine, Ireland
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S089268750300400X
https://ataglance.vedantaresources.com/our-contribution/case-studies/item/25-lisheen-closure
LAWPRO
July 2020
Within the public drinking water source protection area for Drumcliff springs which
supplies Ennis
Hydromorphology (land reclamation)
Small point sources (DWWTS and farmyards)
One operational limestone quarry within the Shallee_010 sub-basin but it discharges
under S4 licence to the Fergus_040 waterbody to the north
EPA licensed facility located beside the quarry (Licence no. P0771) which discharges to ground within the sub basin. There is no process water discharged, only surface water which is discharged to ground from settlement ponds. The discharge is licensed for suspended solids and pH.
Clogrennane Lime Limited (Clare) (CRH)
https://goo.gl/maps/jmhDF5pNnGsT4ZhM7
A quicklime production facility comprising of; Maerz PFR kiln and auxiliary plant, and storage silos
https://epawebapp.epa.ie/licences/lic_eDMS/rss/P0771-02.xml

Non operational limestone quarry at Fountain (closed 2010)

LAWPRO
June 2020
Pressures indicated for Tyshe are agriculture and domestic wastewater
The elevated ammonia concentrations could also indicate the presence of farmyard point sources.
Six domestic wastewater systems with high – very high P impact potential along the north and south tributaries of the Tyshe
Agriculture and urban wastewater are listed as the significant pressures
New WWTP for Ardfert was installed in 2017
Dewatering at the Section 4 quarry
The quarry has a section 4 license and is being dewatered – approximately 2500 m3/d on average
Drinking water abstraction at Ardfert South comes under strain in dry summer

Nitrate concentrations are consistently high
Chloride concentrations are consistently high
Elevated nutrients, including orthophosphate, ammonium and nitrate, as well as sediment, are the
significant issues
Hydromorphology
The Tyshe River, falls within the Banna Drainage District. Kerry County Council has a statutory duty to maintain this Drainage District. The River Tyshe flows to the sea at Blackrock. The outfall at Blackrock is vulnerable to blockage from build-up of sand (Flood Risk Management Plan for the Tralee Bay-Feale River Basin, 2018). Sand and seaweed are excavated out of the channel opening. These works currently take place at least every two weeks, but this can be daily in the winter months. The annual cost of these works is estimated at approximately €150,000. The drainage systems back up when this outfall at Blackrock is not clear. Maintenance work is also carried out to keep tidal flaps, approx. 600m upstream of the outfall, functioning. Sluice gates are manually operated to close on high tides to prevent tide backing up on Tyshe River, once every few weeks (Flood Risk Management Plan for the Tralee Bay-Feale River Basin, 2018). As part of a national Preliminary Flood Risk Assessment, discontinuing the existing regime of removing silt and debris from the outfall at Blackrock is being explored
Sample appeals, 2022
Carhoo Lower & Coolnagearagh, Coachford, County Cork
https://www.pleanala.ie/en-ie/case/310214
Knockanemore, Ovens, Co. Cork
https://www.pleanala.ie/en-ie/case/312510
FARRANASTACK, LISSELTON, CO KERRY
https://www.pleanala.ie/en-ie/case/312502
Commonstown, Moone, Co. Kildare
https://www.pleanala.ie/en-ie/case/312703
Garrans , Stradbally , Co. Laois
https://www.pleanala.ie/en-ie/case/312543
Mullafarry, Killala, County Mayo
https://www.pleanala.ie/en-ie/case/312661
Ballynabarney, Redcross, Co. Wicklow
South Dublin Co Co refer requests for S261 quarries to the EPA website
But this is not the S261 Register. This is the S19 Register which has been developed to meet the obligations of Regulation 19 of the Extractive Industries Regulations 2009. Each Local Authority is required to enter and maintain entries in this S19 register for all extractive industries within its functional area.
It is unclear is South Dublin CoCo have no S261 quarries outside the S19 list below
The following link gives the 2012 documents for the South Dublin quarry review http://www.sdublincoco.ie/Media/Item/23720

Under the AIE Regs to request a list of named quarries with their GPS locations and related water abstraction data, from the dataset known as the Water Abstraction Register
Under the AIE Regs to request any research, reports or enforcement actions relating to the impact of quarries on water quality
In particular, if there is a list of catchments currently under pressure from quarries in the form similar to the other ‘significant pressure reports’
eg https://www.catchments.ie/significant-pressures-urban-waste-water/ or https://www.catchments.ie/significant-pressures-forestry/
Note:
I am submitting the same AIE to both the EPA and LAWPRO (via Tipperary CoCo, as the competent authority for LAWPRO), as I am unclear which entity has oversight for quarry sites
For the purposes of this AIE please consider the timeframe 2018-2022